Social media companies are not working hard enough to remove hate crimes posted on their platforms, according to a parliamentary inquiry.
Facebook, Twitter and Google executives faced tough questions from MPs about how they deal with online abuse.
Chair of the Home Affairs Select Committee, Labour MP Yvette Cooper, asked why YouTube had not removed a video entitled Jews Admit Organising White Genocide.
Peter Barron, vice president of communications and public affairs at Google, which owns YouTube, said: I’m not going to defend the content of the video.
The video I found abhorrent and offensive.
But the important question – and this is a question relating to the wider issues of freedom of expression – is: is that content illegal and does it break our guidelines?
And our policy and legal experts arrived at the conclusion that, no, it didn’t.
The questioning was part of the committee’s inquiry into hate crime and its violent consequences.
It comes as the German government proposed laws that would see tech companies fined up to £43m for not removing hate crime posts quickly enough.
Sky News understands that the UK Government is keeping a similar option under review.
The social media bosses defended their companies’ actions, but Nick Pickles, head of public policy and government for Twitter, admitted the company was not doing a good enough job.
He added that Twitter was trialling new technology to spot abusive and hate crime posts, but said: The positive benefits our platforms bring – and technology brings – come with serious challenges.
Yes, it brings out some of the worst in society but it brings to light things that we all rather did not happen.
But the idea that you can preemptively detect things and remove them before they are posted, we’re never going to get to that point.
Ms Cooper also said: We understand the challenges that you face and technology changes very fast, but you all have millions of users in the United Kingdom and you make billions of pounds from these users, (but) you all have a terrible reputation among users for dealing swiftly with content even against your own community standards.
(c) Sky News 2017: Facebook, Twitter and Google bosses slammed by MPs for failing to ban vile content