The Isle of Wight has only achieved 54 per cent of its housebuilding target over the past three years — leaving it vulnerable to unwanted development.
Its poor record, which left it close to the bottom of the national table, means there is a presumption of approval to applications for schemes within the National Planning Policy Framework.
Between 2017 and 2020, 1,823 homes should have been built to meet government-set targets but only 978 were delivered.
Across the Solent, Southampton achieved 129 per cent against its target but Portsmouth only reached 80 per cent.
Only 17 areas in the country had worse housing levels than the Island, all falling below the thresholds which means their planning authorities are subject to the strongest sanctions.
Planning policies the council use for the delivery of new homes can now be viewed as out of date so when determining the applications. The planning authority may, in some cases, have to rely on national ones instead.
Due to the presumption, this argument is used by planning agents when stating why their schemes should be approved.
It does not automatically mean, however, the application will be approved but that it should only be rejected if significant and demonstrable harm would outweigh the benefits.
The council is under further sanctions because it cannot demonstrate the number of homes permitted and expected to be built in a five year period — despite the number of already-approved developments.
Speaking at the March meeting of the planning committee, Cllr Richard Hollis listed developments including Harcourt Sands, Pennyfeathers and Rosemary Vineyard in Ryde, and Place Road in Cowes, all with planning permission, some yet to be built.
He said adding up the developments, he did not believe that figure failed governments targets.
An Isle of Wight Council spokesperson said recent court cases have helped the planning authority consider how the presumption is applied to applications.
While policies may be out of date they potentially remain relevant and should be considered when passing judgement.
They said the council will continue the Island Plan Core Strategy while the next-generation Island Planning Strategy (IPS) is being finalised.
“The IPS provides the opportunity to ‘reset’ our approach towards providing new homes on the Island,” the spokesperson said.
To help build the next IPS, people have been asked to identify brownfield, or previously developed land, that could be potential development sites.
By Louise Hill, Local Democracy Reporter
Councillor Coy On Isle Of Wight Social Housing
Warning For Islanders Selling Vehicles To Be 'Scam Aware'
Bus Fares Set To Rise Following Council Meeting
Small Business Support Proposal Passed By Isle Of Wight Council
Isle Of Wight Residents Encouraged To nominate Charity To Receive Festive Financial Boost
Five-Year Isle Of Wight Area Of Outstanding Natural Beauty Plan Unanimously Approved
More Islanders Cross The Solent With Wightlink’s Discounted Fares For NHS Appointments
Hampshire And Isle Of Wight Air Ambulance Funds Defibrillators For The Community
Isle Of Wight Council Budget Pressures Likely To Continue Following Autumn Statement
Council Approves Support Package To Help Islanders On Low Incomes
Isle Of Wight Councillor In Mental Health Priority Motion
Bird Keepers Urged To Remain Vigilant Following Increased Avian Influenza Risk
Island Pupils Receive Lesson In Road Safety That Could Save Lives
New Shanklin Flats Given Green Light
Joe Robertson Appointed Parliamentary Private Secretary For Shadow Culture, Media And Sport
Shanklin Company Making Nuclear Waste Sorting Safer, Greener And Cheaper
Five-Year Isle Of Wight Landscape Plan Decision On Horizon
Help Sought For Isle Of Wight's Struggling Small Businesses
Primary School Admissions For September 2025 Now Open
Island Families Invited To Take Tour Of St Mary's Special Care Baby Unit
